SC sometimes looks at well-studied problems and almost always, there's an alternative explanation lurking there, somewhere.
Arjun is paralysed in the Kurkshetra battlefield when he sees that he has to fight his own people and kill them. Hamlet, is paralysed by something, too and refrains from killing his stepfather. Before we delve into the underlying psychopathology of these situations, are we missing something obvious?
Let's illustrate this by picturing a scene where we let these two gentlemen interact with a stereotypical South Indian boss - by that, I mean, efficient (yefishent), no-nonsense and smart, who calls them for a performance appraisal.
Scene 1 : Hamlet
Boss (B) : So, did you finish off that fellow's chapter?
Hamlet (H) : Sir, I did not.
B : Why not? Waiting for auspicious timea?
H : I thought about it and...
B : You think alsovaa?
H : I'm faced with moral issues in this matter. I cannot murder
B : How come you killed off all those other fellows then? That is ant-bite and this is murder?
H : Then I identify with him because of this Oedipus complex thingie I have.
B : Same story you gave last time also. You said you'll get it done through someone.
H : Yeah, but.
B : No but but. Either you tell me your problem or find some other job, like in Denmark GPO.
H : There is no problem. I'm just a little lazy, that's all. Will be done today.
Scene 2 : Arjun
B : Come, sir, come. What I owe this honour to?
A : Sir, you only called me.
B : Have you started the war with your cousins?
A : No. How can I fight my own relatives? My own Guru, my great grandfather...
B : Stop. Ok leave this war. There's another war without any blood relatives. You go there and fight. I'll transfer you there.
A : No, sir. I can't fight in general. I'm peace loving.
B : Oho? very good very good. You do the filing then for this office.
A : (breaks down) Sir, I can't do anything. I admit it, I'm just a bum. All my issues with fighting were made up.
See? They were just lazy people. Now, was that so hard?
Arjun is paralysed in the Kurkshetra battlefield when he sees that he has to fight his own people and kill them. Hamlet, is paralysed by something, too and refrains from killing his stepfather. Before we delve into the underlying psychopathology of these situations, are we missing something obvious?
Let's illustrate this by picturing a scene where we let these two gentlemen interact with a stereotypical South Indian boss - by that, I mean, efficient (yefishent), no-nonsense and smart, who calls them for a performance appraisal.
Scene 1 : Hamlet
Boss (B) : So, did you finish off that fellow's chapter?
Hamlet (H) : Sir, I did not.
B : Why not? Waiting for auspicious timea?
H : I thought about it and...
B : You think alsovaa?
H : I'm faced with moral issues in this matter. I cannot murder
B : How come you killed off all those other fellows then? That is ant-bite and this is murder?
H : Then I identify with him because of this Oedipus complex thingie I have.
B : Same story you gave last time also. You said you'll get it done through someone.
H : Yeah, but.
B : No but but. Either you tell me your problem or find some other job, like in Denmark GPO.
H : There is no problem. I'm just a little lazy, that's all. Will be done today.
Scene 2 : Arjun
B : Come, sir, come. What I owe this honour to?
A : Sir, you only called me.
B : Have you started the war with your cousins?
A : No. How can I fight my own relatives? My own Guru, my great grandfather...
B : Stop. Ok leave this war. There's another war without any blood relatives. You go there and fight. I'll transfer you there.
A : No, sir. I can't fight in general. I'm peace loving.
B : Oho? very good very good. You do the filing then for this office.
A : (breaks down) Sir, I can't do anything. I admit it, I'm just a bum. All my issues with fighting were made up.
See? They were just lazy people. Now, was that so hard?